I found a pod cast involving the Teaching Council and ERO.
As far as I can gather the council wants appraisals to be about growth and development rather than compliance or accountability.
They note that there is a shared responsibility to meet the legal requirements of appraisals. The council needs to ensure that the issue and renewal of practising certificates is based on an appraisal of a consistent and reasonable standard, boards and professional leaders must ensure there is an effective appraisal process at their place and teachers and other leaders with practising certificates must participate in the process.
Appraisal should be a chance for teachers to reflect on their practice and think deeply about the relationship between what they do and the outcomes for their learners ( well being as well as achievement), their colleagues and the Standard
3 prongs
How does what I do impact on others?
How does it fit the Standards?
How can the Standards support me to work more effectively ?
So there is an evidence component but also a conversation component
It should be collaborative
How does the appraisal support teaching and learning across the school?
The council sees evidence in two ways
The teacher needs evidence that they have participated in a system eg observations, notes from conversations, evidence of a process
Relates to the Quality Practice Template and the Standards, evidence may be in it’s naturally occurring place, eg planning
Then could be conversations around your goals, an example of important practice and learning for you or could be focused on inquiry.
Check Evidence: Putting together a folder or portfolio
How are you using the information or evidence to improve your teaching
ERO is looking for alignment - a clear line of sight between what it is, what’s happening and what’s trying to be achieved and what the outcome of that is.
I’m assuming this means that we are actually doing what we say we are doing.
Evidence could be:
Notes from student voice
Planning
Examples of practice
Learnings from students
Piece of policy that helped you decide on that approach
Research
Feedback on observations
Readings
Notes from conversations with mentor
Evidence to show how students were engaged
What learning was like
What achievement was like
Ie evidence to help you understand the relationship between your teaching, the outcomes for learners and the Standards
Curate evidence in a way that is readily accessible, but also be able to articulate where the links are and how they’re made
Reflections:
There is no one right way to do appraisals.
We don't need tons of evidence- more of higher quality is better
Appraisal should improve my practice
There is a further reading about appraisal which I have also added to the blog. Appraisals are obviously a current issue
Next steps
I would like to get my Play based learning information sorted to properly develop my 'why' as well as improve my 'how,' as an inquiry for appraisal
continue to link blog to appraisal document
- Engagement with school management systems and appraisal documentation/practices that lead to regular goal setting and review.
- Professional learning and development that aligns with the goals or next steps identified in the appraisal process and renewal of my practising certificate.
- Professional leader and colleague appraisal conversations that inform decisions around PLD needs.